The short answer
Under the current rules — indexation capped at the lower of CPI or WPI (2–4% typical), the new $67,000 threshold with marginal 15c/17c/10c rates, and the 20% balance reduction already applied — a typical $32,000 post-cut HECS balance takes 7 to 13 years to fully repay for a graduate whose income trajectory is normal (starting $72k, rising to $125k over 10 years). Total indexation paid across that period: $6,500 – $11,000, materially less than under pre-2025 rules.
Three FY2025-26 scenario projections
All three scenarios use a 3% projected long-run indexation rate and assume the 20% cut has already been applied.
Scenario A: fast payer — $32,000 start (post-cut), $95,000 starting income
Under the new marginal system, repayment at $95,000 = 15c × ($95,000 − $67,000) = $4,200 per year. With 3% indexation, balance trajectory: Y1 end $28,160 ($32,960 after indexation less $4,200 repayment plus income growth). Income rises to ~$120k by Y6, repayment ~$9,000; Y8 balance below $5,000. Debt cleared at Year 8. Total indexation paid: roughly $5,800.
Scenario B: average payer — $32,000 start, $72,000 starting income
Rate at $72,000 = 15c × $5,000 = $750/year — far lower than the old 3% whole-of-income figure. Indexation ($960 at 3%) exceeds repayment in Y1, balance grows slightly. Income rises to $85k by Y3 (repayment $2,700), crosses $100k by Y6 (repayment $4,950). Debt cleared around Year 12. Total indexation paid: roughly $9,500.
Scenario C: slow-starter — $48,000 start, $65,000 starting income
At $65,000, below the $67,000 threshold — zero compulsory repayment. Balance indexates only. Y1 $49,440, Y2 $50,923, Y3 $52,451. Income crosses $67k in Y3 (now $75, repayment $1,200); repayment climbs as income grows. Debt cleared around Year 19. Total indexation paid: $22,000+ over 19 years — still materially below the pre-reform equivalent because the marginal system doesn't punish you the moment you cross the threshold.
How the 20% cut and marginal system changed long-term cost
For identical income trajectories, a graduate in FY2025-26 pays roughly 30–45% less total indexation over the life of the debt than the equivalent graduate would have under FY2024-25 rules. Two effects stack:
- 20% smaller starting balance → 20% less indexation per year → 20% less total indexation.
- Marginal repayment formula → lower repayment at low-to-middle incomes means more principal outstanding longer early in the career. But the total saved in repayment usually flows into higher voluntary repayments or investments that more than offset the extra indexation.
What drives total cost
- Starting balance. Linear — double the balance, double the time to pay.
- Income trajectory. Higher and faster growth means you cross the 15c and 17c brackets earlier, repaying more principal while indexation is still low in dollar terms.
- Indexation rate. The CPI/WPI cap limits the worst case, but steady 3% over 20 years still doubles an untouched balance.
- Voluntary repayments. Strategic voluntary payments before 1 June in high-indexation years cut lifetime cost the most.
What this means for the early-repayment decision
For graduates in Scenario A, HECS is cheap — roughly $5,800 over 8 years on a $32,000 post-cut balance is 18% of starting balance, comparable to low-rate personal loan interest. Paying early only makes sense if your after-tax return can't beat projected 2.5–3.4% 2026 indexation.
For graduates in Scenario C, total indexation cost of $22,000+ is significant. Aggressive voluntary repayment while income is rising can cut that by half — our voluntary repayment calculator models exactly this against investing the same money.